How One Question Saved Ferrari from a Deepfake Scam

The Call That Almost Worked

In July 2024, an executive at Ferrari—the legendary Italian luxury sports car manufacturer—received an unexpected series of messages on WhatsApp. The sender claimed to be CEO Benedetto Vigna, and the profile picture showed Vigna standing confidently in front of the iconic Ferrari logo.

The messages were urgent: a significant acquisition was in the works, Italy's market regulator had been informed, and the executive's immediate assistance was required.

A Convincing Impersonation

When a follow-up call came through, the voice on the other end was unmistakably Vigna's—or so it seemed. The AI had perfectly captured the CEO's distinctive Southern Italian accent, his speech patterns, and even his tone of authority.

According to Bloomberg, the scammer discussed a confidential deal that required urgent financial transactions. The impersonation was sophisticated enough that it might have worked—if not for the executive's instincts.

The Question That Exposed Everything

Something felt slightly off. Perhaps it was a subtle inconsistency in tone, or the unusual communication channel (WhatsApp instead of official channels). Whatever triggered the suspicion, the executive decided to verify the caller's identity with a simple test.

"What was the title of the book you recommended to me last week?"

The question was personal, specific, and something only the real Benedetto Vigna would know. Unable to answer, the scammer abruptly ended the call.

Why This Matters

The Ferrari incident, reported by Fortune and MIT Sloan Management Review, illustrates both the sophistication of modern deepfake attacks and the simple human factors that can defeat them.

What the attackers got right:

- Voice cloning: The AI accurately mimicked Vigna's accent and speech patterns - Visual identity: A legitimate-looking WhatsApp profile with the CEO's photo - Context building: A plausible scenario involving a confidential acquisition - Urgency creation: Time pressure to prevent careful verification

What ultimately failed:

- Personal knowledge: The AI couldn't know private conversations between executives - Human intuition: The executive sensed something was wrong despite the technical sophistication

The Anatomy of CEO Deepfake Fraud

According to security experts quoted by MIT Sloan Management Review, deepfakes are created using generative adversarial networks (GANs)—AI systems where two neural networks compete:

1. The generator creates fake media
2. The discriminator evaluates how realistic it appears
3. They iterate until the fakes are nearly indistinguishable from reality

For CEOs and public figures, training data is abundant: interviews, earnings calls, conference presentations, and social media provide hours of audio and video that can be used to train these models.

Building Organizational Resilience

The Ferrari case offers a blueprint for defense:

1. Establish Verification Protocols

Create pre-arranged code words or personal questions that only legitimate parties would know. Update these regularly.

2. Question Unusual Channels

Official business should happen through official channels. A CEO requesting urgent financial transactions via WhatsApp should immediately raise red flags.

3. Trust Your Instincts

If something feels off—even if you can't articulate why—verify through independent means before proceeding.

4. Implement Multi-Factor Verification

For high-value transactions, require verification through multiple independent channels (phone call + email confirmation + in-person if possible).

5. Deploy Technical Defenses

Use deepfake detection technology that can analyze audio and video for signs of synthetic generation.

The Escalating Threat

Ferrari isn't alone. Deloitte predicts deepfake-enabled fraud will reach $40 billion by 2027. As the technology becomes more accessible, attacks are moving from targeting Fortune 500 companies to mid-size enterprises and even small businesses.

The key insight from Ferrari's near-miss: technology alone cannot defeat technology-enhanced social engineering. The most effective defense combines technical solutions with human awareness and verification protocols.

The Simple Defense That Works

The executive who saved Ferrari millions didn't need sophisticated AI detection tools in that moment. They needed:

1. Awareness that deepfakes exist and target executives
2. Suspicion when something felt slightly wrong
3. A verification method that the attacker couldn't fake

As attacks become more sophisticated, organizations must build verification into their culture—making it normal, not awkward, to verify identity before acting on high-stakes requests.

---

Nevrial provides hardware-backed identity verification that goes beyond personal questions. Our cryptographic proofs ensure you always know who you're really talking to. See how it works.